Cincinnati Pizza Month Rankings

In October of 2017, my fiancé and I decided to celebrate National Pizza Month in the best way: by eating pizza at a different pizza shop every day of the month! Somehow, we actually pulled it off. (My taste buds were thrilled. My complexion not so much…)

For consistency’s sake,, I ate only cheese pizza for the month, and Drew had his favorite toppings: chicken, bacon & green peppers every day. Below are our final rankings from best to worst of all the places we tried.

KATIE’S RANKINGS

Dewey's — 8.8

Flying Pizza — 8.8

Goodfellas — 8.6

Two Cities — 7.5

Ferarri's — 7.3

La Rosas — 7.3

Rudino's — 7.2

The Works — 7.2

Richard's — 7.1

Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta — 7

Mellow Mushroom — 7

Pizzeria Locale — 6.8

Rapid Fired — 6.8

MOD pizza — 6.7

Ramundo's — 6.7

Roc-a-Fella's — 6.7

Stone Lanes — 6.6

Mio's — 6.5

Cucinova — 6.4

Betta's — 6.3

Padrino's — 6.3

Fratelli's — 6.1

Catch-A-Fire — 5.9

Victory Lane — 5.7

Fireside — 5.6

Adriaticos — 5.4

Italianette — 5.2

Blaze — 5

Trotta's — 5

A Tavola — 4.8

Westshore — 3.6

DREW’S RANKINGS

Dewey's — 9

Flying Pizza — 9

Two Cities — 8.1

Roc-a-Fella's — 7.9

Goodfellas — 7.6

Rudino's — 7.5

Richard's — 7.3

Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta — 7.2

Ramundo's — 7.2

The Works — 7.2

Ferarri's — 7.1

Mellow Mushroom — 7.1

Rapid Fired — 7.1

Betta's — 7

La Rosas — 6.9

Padrino's — 6.9

Stone Lanes — 6.9

Italianette — 6.8

Victory Lane — 6.8

Adriaticos — 6.7

Mio's — 6.7

Cucinova — 6.6

Fratelli's — 6.4

Blaze — 6.2

MOD pizza — 6.2

Pizzeria Locale — 6.2

Fireside — 6.1

Trotta's — 6

Catch-A-Fire — 5.6

A Tavola — 4.6

Westshore — 4.3